Over 40 years combined experience

Reel Mayhem was established in 2018 by the Pace brothers, beginning as a 6 passenger fishing charter. In the winter of 2019 they began their waterfowl hunting, which became such a success in the Long Island Sound, they created a custom built blind for all their customers.

The Captains & Crew members have spent their lifetime fishing & Hunting and have the experience and knowledge to make your trip whether Hunting or Fishing nothing but exceptional.

Equipped with a 50ft x 15ft Chesapeake Coast Guard certified for up to 28 people we are a full service fishing charter boat, supplying all bait and tackle on all trips. Setting the bar for fishing in The Long Island, we are conveniently located behind Rudy's Tackle Barn in Greenwich, Ct on the Byram River. Starting out in City Island, NY we realized the closer we are to the fish, the less travel time and more fishing time for our customers.